Evil Cake Genius Reviews

I bought a couple of these templates hoping they’d be useful across fondant, buttercream, and ganache, but they ended up being inconsistent. A few parts worked okay with one medium, then totally missed the mark with another. I had to redo sections and wasted more cake time than I expected, which was frustrating. The support info also wasn’t clear enough to help me troubleshoot. For what I paid, I expected them to be more versatile, so I wouldn’t buy them again.

I ordered from evilcakegenius.com, and while I did end up finding what I needed, I kind of regret not giving myself more time to figure everything out. The products were there, but some of the pages felt cluttered, and I kept having to click around more than I expected.

The checkout did go through eventually, and I got my confirmation, so it wasn’t a disaster or anything. I just wish the whole process had been smoother, because it made a simple order feel more frustrating than it needed to be.

I had a question about my order and reached out to customer service. As someone who really doesn’t like having to chase people for answers, I appreciated that they got back to me quickly and explained things clearly. It wasn’t instant, and I did have to follow up once, so I’m taking off one star, but overall they were helpful when I needed them.

I’ve dealt with a few returns at other places, and this one was easy compared to most. Nothing amazing, but the refund came through quickly and the whole thing was handled fine.

I used the promo code and, shockingly, it actually went through without making me jump through a million hoops. Saved me some cash, which is all I wanted in the first place. Why can’t more discounts just work like this?

I ordered a few cake tools from Evil Cake Genius and they showed up just fine. Everything was packed nicely, nothing was damaged, and the items looked like what I expected from the photos.

The only thing that bugged me was the shipping cost. It felt a bit high for the small stuff I was buying, and I almost backed out at checkout because of it.

Overall I’m happy with what I got and I’d probably order again, but I do wish there were cheaper shipping options. That’s about it.

I was hoping this site would actually help with more professional cake projects, but i ran out of patience fast. Some of the ideas are cute, sure, but when you need real steps, planning details, or anything beyond basic inspiration, it feels thin.

For casual hobby baking, it’s probably fine. But for paid cake work, I didn’t find it useful enough to keep digging around. I ended up closing it and looking somewhere else that got to the point.

I picked up some cake stencils and cutters from evilcakegenius.com, they’ve been solid. I’ve already used them on what feels like a million orders, and they’re still holding up fine. They just need a careful wash after each use. They’re not absolutely perfect, but they’re definitely useful and have saved me a ton of time...

Was hoping for a few more updates along the way. Communication wasn’t bad, just could’ve been a bit better.

My order was basically accurate, just one tiny thing was off. Still, compared to some other places...

I ordered a few moulds and tools, and they feel really solid. The details come out nice and clean, and nothing feels cheap or flimsy. The shipping box was packed well too, which I appreciated. I have used them twice now and they still look new. I am very happy with everything...

I’ve used this for cutting cake pieces, and it made the job so much easier. The cuts came out really neat and even, much cleaner than when I try to do it by hand. It saved me a lot of time and frustration. Shipping wasn’t the fastest, but it was fine overall. I’m happy with it and would definitely order again

I ordered this thinking it would get here in time, which I guess is partly on me for cutting it a little close, but the shipping ended up taking forever. I didn’t really get clear updates either, so I was just sitting around wondering where it was. Frustrating overall, and I probably wouldn’t order again.

I mostly noticed the designs right away, they’re original and definitely not the same old cakes you see everywhere. Some details weren’t perfect if you look closely, but i was more focused on how fun and creative the ideas were overall.

I was kind of expecting to have to ask for an apology if it showed up looking different, but it actually matched the pictures exactly. No surprises there.

The cake topper itself was fine, but the packaging was rough. The box showed up bent and the plastic sleeve was loose, so it looked kind of messy. Nothing was actually broken, but it definitely didn’t feel gift-ready, which seems avoidable.

I do really like the cake tools here, honestly. The selection looks great, which makes it even more impressive how often the stuff I need is out of stock. I kept checking back hoping to finish my order, but half the items for my project were still unavailable. It’s a good place to shop in theory, just kind of frustrating when you’re trying to actually buy something.

I paid for my order on evilcakegenius.com and, to be fair, everything did go through just fine. I got the confirmation email quickly too, so in the end there was no actual disaster, even though my brain was absolutely preparing for one.

The checkout just felt a bit clunky and slow, and for a minute I was staring at the screen like, did I just pay twice, did I pay zero times, have I broken the internet? It all worked out, but the process could definitely be smoother.

I ordered from outside the US and, to be fair, the items arrived in good shape and nothing was broken. But the tracking barely updated and customs felt like it took forever. I’m not the most patient person, so the lack of clear delivery info got annoying fast. Overall it was okay, but I really wish the shipping updates were better...

I had an issue with my order and, to be fair, support did eventually get it sorted. But it took way longer than it should have, and I had to follow up more than once. I already had a feeling their support might be slow, and this experience kind of confirmed it for me.